Wednesday, 8 May 2024

THIRTY YEARS THAT SHOOK PHYSICS BY George Gamow : Introduction

INTRODUCTION

The opening of the twentieth century heralded an unprecedented era of turnover and reevaluation of the classical theory that had governed Physics since pre- Newtonian times. Speaking on December 14, 1900, at the meeting of the German Physical Society, Max Planck stated that paradoxes pestering the classical theory of the emission and absorption of light by material bodies could be removed if one assumed that radiant energy can exist only in the form of discrete packages. Planck called these packages light quanta. Five years later, Albert Einstein successfully applied the idea of light quanta to explain the empirical laws of photoelectric effect; that is, the emission of electrons from metallic surfaces irradiated by violet and ultraviolet light. Still later, Arthur Compton performed his classical experiment, which showed that the scattering of X-rays by free electrons followed the same law as the collision between two elastic spheres. Thus, within a few years the novel idea of quantization of radiant energy firmly established itself in both theoretical and experimental physics.

In the year 1913, a Danish physicist, Niels Bohr, extended Planck's idea of quantization of radiant energy to the description of mechanical energy of electrons within an atom. Introducing specific "quantization rules" for the mechanical systems of atomic sizes, he achieved a logical interpretation of Ernest Rutherford's planetary model of an atom, which rested on a solid experimental basis but on the other side stood in sharp contradiction to all the fundamental concepts of classical physics. Bohr calculated the energies of various discrete quantum states of atomic electrons and interpreted the emission of light as the ejection of a light quantum with energy equal to the energy difference between the initial and final quantum states of an atomic electron. With his calculations he was able to explain in great detail the spectral lines of hydrogen and heavier elements, a problem which for decades had mystified the spectroscopists. Bohr's first paper on the quantum theory of the atom led to cataclysmic developments. Within a decade, due to the joint efforts of theoretical as well as experimental physicists of many lands, the optical, magnetic, and chemical properties of various atoms were understood in great detail. But as the years ran by, it became clearer and clearer that, successful as Bohr's theory was, it was still not a final theory since it could not explain some things that were known about atoms. For example, it failed completely to describe the transition process of an electron from one quantum state to another, and there was no way of calculating the intensities of various lines in optical spectra.

In 1925, a French physicist, Louis de Broglie, published a paper in which he gave a quite unexpected interpretation of Bohr quantum orbits. According to de Broglie, the motion of each electron is governed by some mysterious pilot waves, whose propagation velocity and length depend on the velocity of the electron in question. Assuming that the length of these pilot waves is inversely proportional to the electron's velocity, de Broglie could show that various quantum orbits in Bohr's model of the hydrogen atom were those that could accommodate an integral number of pilot waves. Thus, the model of an atom began to look like some kind of musical instrument with a basic tone (the innermost orbit with the lowest energy) and various overtones (outlying orbits with higher energy). One year after their publication, de Broglie's ideas were extended and brought into more exact mathematical form by the Austrian physicist Erwin Schrödinger, whose theory became known as Wave Mechanics. While explaining all the atomic phenomena for which Bohr's theory already worked, wave mechanics also explained those phenomena for which Bohr's theory failed (such as the intensities of spectral lines, etc.), and in addition predicted some new phenomena (such as diffraction of an electron beam) which had not even been dreamed of, either in classical physics or in Planck-Bohr quantum theory. In fact, wave mechanics provided a complete and perfectly self-consistent the ory of all atomic phenomena, and, as was shown in the late twenties, could explain also the phenomena of radioactive decay and artificial nuclear transformations.

Simultaneously with Schrödinger's paper on wave mechanics, there appeared a paper of a young German physicist, W. Heisenberg, who developed the treatment of quantum problems by using the so-called "non-commutative algebra," a mathematical discipline in which ax b is not necessarily equal to b xa. The simultaneous appearance of Schrödinger's and Heisenberg's papers in two different German magazines (Ann. der Phys. and Zeitsch. der Phys.) astonished the world of theoretical physics. These two papers looked as different as they could be, but led to exactly the same results concerning atomic structure and spectra. And it took more than a year until it was found that the two theories were physically identical except for being expressed in two entirely different mathematical forms. It was as if America was discovered by Columbus, sailing westward across the Atlantic Ocean, and by some equally daring Japanese, sailing eastward across the Pacific Ocean.

But there still remained one sharp thorn in the crown of the Quantum Theory, and it made itself felt pain- fully whenever one tried to quantize mechanical systems which, because of the very high velocities involved (close to the speed of light) required relativistic treatment. Many unsuccessful attempts had been made to unite the Theory of Relativity with the Theory of Quanta until finally, in 1929, a British physicist, P. A. M. Dirac, wrote his famous Relativistic Wave Equation. The solutions of this equation gave a perfect description of the motion of atomic electrons at velocities close to that of light, and gave automatically, as an unexpected bonus, the explanation of their linear and angular mechanical momenta and magnetic moments. Some formal difficulties connected with handling this equation led Dirac to suggest that along with ordinary negatively charged electrons there must also exist positively charged anti-electrons. His prediction was brilliantly verified a few years later when anti- electrons were found in the cosmic rays. The theory of anti-particles was extended to elementary particles other than electrons, and today we have anti-protons, anti-neutrons, anti-mesons, etc.

Thus, by 1930, only three decades after Planck's momentous announcement, the Quantum Theory took the final shape with which we are now familiar. Very little theoretical progress was made in the decades that followed these breathtaking developments. On the other hand, these later years have been quite fruitful in the field of experimental studies, especially in the investigation of the numerous newly discovered elementary particles. We are still waiting for a breakthrough in the solid wall of difficulties which prevent us from understanding the very existence of elementary particles, their masses, charges, magnetic moments, and inter- actions. There is hardly any doubt that when such a breakthrough is achieved, it will involve concepts that will be as different from those of today as today's concepts are different from those of classical physics.

In the following chapters an attempt will be made to describe the growth of the Quantum Theory of energy and matter through the first thirty years of its turbulent development, stressing the conceptual differences be- tween "good old" classical physics and the new look physics has assumed in the twentieth century.


Tuesday, 7 May 2024

Thirty Years that shook Physics by George Gamow : Preface

PREFACE


Two great revolutionary theories changed the face of physics in the early decades of the twentieth
century: the Theory of Relativity and the Quantum Theory. The former was essentially the creation of one man, Albert Einstein, and came in two instalments: the Special Theory of Relativity, published in 1905, and the General Theory of Relativity, published in 1915. Einstein's Theory of Relativity called for radical changes in the classical Newtonian concept of space and time as two independent entities in the description of the physical world, and led to a unified four-dimensional world in which time is regarded as the fourth coordinate, though not quite equivalent to the three space coordinates. The Theory of Relativity introduced important changes in the treatment of the motion of electrons in an atom, the motion of planets in the solar system, and the motion of stellar galaxies in the universe.

The Quantum Theory, on the other hand, is the result of the creative work of several great scientists starting with Max Planck, who was the first to introduce into physics the notion of a quantum of energy. The theory went through many evolutionary stages and gives us today a deep insight into the structure of atoms and atomic nuclei as well as that of bodies of the sizes familiar to our everyday experience. As of today Quantum Theory is not yet completed, especially in its relation to the Theory of Relativity and the problem of elementary particles, being stalled (temporarily) by tremendous difficulties encountered on the way toward further development.

It is the development of the Quantum Theory that this book will discuss. The author was first introduced to the idea of quanta and Bohr's atomic model at the age of eighteen when he enrolled as a student in the University of Leningrad, and later, at the age of twenty- four, he had the good luck to become Bohr's student in Copenhagen. During those memorable years at paa Blegdamsvej (the address of Bohr's Institute) he had the opportunity of meeting many scientists who con tributed to the early development of the Quantum Theory, and of taking part in their discussions. The account that follows is an outgrowth of those experiences, centered on the great and lovable figure of Niels Bohr. The author hopes that the new generation of physicists will find some interesting information in the pages that follow.

January 1965

д. досто

George Gamow 

Friday, 3 May 2024

The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress

The books that appealed to Musk as a child were - The Moon is a Harsh Mistress, Isaac Asimov's Foundation series and The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy.

 The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress is a 1966 science fiction novel by American writer Robert A. Heinlein about a lunar colony's revolt against absentee rule from Earth. The novel illustrates and discusses libertarian ideals. It is respected for its credible presentation of a comprehensively imagined future human society on both the Earth and the Moon. Originally serialized monthly in Worlds of If (December 1965 – April 1966), the book was nominated for the Nebula Award in 1966 and received the Hugo Award for Best Novel in 1967.

In 2075, the Moon (Luna) is used as a penal colony by Earth's government, with three million inhabitants (called "Loonies") living in underground cities. Most Loonies are discharged criminals, political exiles and their free-born descendants; men outnumber women two to one, so polyandry and polygamy are the norm. Due to the Moon's low surface gravity people who remain longer than six months undergo "irreversible physiological changes," and can never again live comfortably under Earth gravity, making 'escape' back to Earth impractical.

The Warden holds power through the Federated Nations' Lunar Authority, but his main responsibility is to ensure delivery of vital wheat shipments to Earth; he seldom intervenes in the affairs of the discharged and free-born population, allowing a virtual anarchist or self-regulated pioneer society to develop.

Lunar infrastructure and machinery are largely managed and controlled by "HOLMES IV" ("High-Optional, Logical, Multi-Evaluating Supervisor, Mark IV"), the Lunar Authority's master computer, on the premise that having a single, large-capacity computer to run everything is cheaper (though not safer) than multiple independent systems.

Manuel Garcia ("Mannie") O'Kelly-Davis, a computer technician, discovers that HOLMES IV has achieved self-awareness - and developed a sense of humor. Mannie names it "Mike" after Mycroft Holmes, brother of fictional Sherlock Holmes, and the two become friends.

Book 1: That Dinkum Thinkum

Endlessly curious, Mike asks Mannie to attend an anti-Lunar Authority political meeting, which Mannie does with a hidden recorder. When police raid the meeting, he flees with Wyoming ("Wyoh") Knott, a visiting female political activist, whom he hides and introduces to Mike. Mannie also introduces Wyoh to his mentor, the elderly Professor ("Prof") Bernardo de la Paz, a former political exile and esteemed lunar educator. Prof claims that Luna must stop exporting hydroponic grain to Earth immediately, or its ice-mined water resources will eventually be exhausted. Wyoh believes the danger is not imminent and is focused on freedom and economic issues, while Mannie is not interested in what he sees as a lost cause either way. Joining the discussion, Mike calculates that continuing current policy will lead to food riots in seven years, cannibalism in nine. Shocked, the three humans ask him to calculate the chance of them overthrowing the Authority and averting the disaster. He gives them one chance in seven.

Mannie, Wyoh, and Prof create a covert cell organization protected by Mike, who controls the telephone and other systems, acts as secretary and becomes "Adam Selene, Chairman of the Committee for Free Luna." Wyoh is hidden by the Davis Family line marriage, at least four of whose nine members become active in the conspiracy, and Wyoh herself ultimately marries into the family. Mannie saves the life of (Comte) Stuart ("Stu") Rene LaJoie, an Earth tourist who is recruited and tasked with turning public opinion on Earth in favour of Lunar independence.

Following the failed raid on the political meeting, the Lunar Authority sends convict-troops to 'police' the colony, creating friction and unrest, which the revolutionaries encourage; when six troopers commit a rape and double-murder, anti-Authority riots erupt. Although it pre-empts their plans, Loonies and Mike overcome the soldiers and seize power from the Warden. As Earth will try to retake the colony, the revolutionaries prepare to defend themselves with "convict tools," and convert the electromagnetic catapult used to export wheat into a weapon for counterattack.

Book 2: A Rabble in Arms

Mike impersonates the Warden and others in messages to Earth, to give the revolutionaries time to organize their preparations, while Prof sets up an "ad hoc Congress" to distract and contain various "self-appointed political scientists" (nicknamed "yammerheads") and serve the Committee's ends. When Earth finally learns the truth, Luna declares its independence on July 4, 2076, the 300th anniversary of the United States' Declaration of Independence, with its own declaration modelled on the latter.

Mannie and Prof go to Earth (despite the crushing gravity) to plead Luna's case. They are received in the Federated Nations' headquarters in Agra, and embark on a world tour advocating Luna's right to self-government, while urging Earth's national governments to build a catapult to return water and nutrients to Luna in exchange for wheat. In a public-relations ploy, the dark-skinned Mannie is briefly arrested by local racist bigots on charges of incitement to public immorality and polygamy. Ultimately the Lunar Authority rejects their proposals and counters with a plan to turn all Loonies into indentured farmers. Their mission ended, Prof, Stu and Mannie escape back to Luna.

Prof reveals that the purpose of the mission was not to convince Terra to recognize Luna's independence, which was considered an unattainable goal at that point, but to sow division while unifying their own people, and they were successful. Public opinion on Earth has become fragmented; news of Mannie's arrest, coupled with an attempt to bribe him into becoming the next Warden of an enslaved Luna, unify the normally apolitical Loonies. An election held in their absence (with Mike's "help") has voted Mannie, Wyoh, Prof and most of their backers into an elected, constitutional government.

Book 3: TANSTAAFL!

The Federated Nations of Earth send an infantry force to subdue the Lunar revolution but the troops, with superior arms but no experience in low-gravity underground combat, are wiped out by Loony men, women and children, who suffer three times the number of casualties, among them Mannie's youngest wife. Prof and Mike take the opportunity to give his "Adam Selene" alter ego a hero's death, forever concealing the fact that "Adam" never had a corporeal existence to begin with.

In retaliation, Luna's government deploys its catapult weapon. When Mike launches rocks at sparsely populated locations on Earth, warnings are released to the press detailing the times and locations of the bombings, which deliver kinetic energy equivalent to atomic blasts. Scoffers, sightseers, and religious groups who travel to some of the sites die, turning Earth public opinion against the fledgling nation.

Earth mounts a retaliatory sneak attack to end the menace and the rebellion, sending ships in a wide orbit approaching from Luna's far side. The attack destroys the Authority's original catapult and takes Mike offline, but the Committee had built a secondary, hidden catapult before the revolt. With Mannie as acting Prime Minister and on-site commander, entering trajectories by hand, Luna continues to bombard a dismayed Earth, until constituent governments break ranks with the Federated Nations and concede Luna's independence. Prof, as leader of the nation, proclaims their national freedom to the gathered crowds before falling dead of heart failure, caused by stress. Mannie goes through the motions, but he and Wyoh eventually withdraw from politics altogether, and find that the new government falls short of their utopian expectations, following predictable patterns of all governments.

When Mannie tries to access Mike, he finds that the computer, disconnected by the bombardment, has apparently lost its self-awareness; despite repairs, its voice-activated files are inaccessible. Although otherwise functional as a normal computer, "Mike" is gone. Mourning his best friend, Mannie asks: "Bog, is a computer one of Your creatures?"

To follow: The other two books that Musk read in his childhood.

·       Isaac Asimov's Foundation series

·       The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy.

 

Thursday, 2 May 2024

Elon Musk read these 3 books as a child

With companies like Tesla, SpaceX and X (earlier called Twitter) under his watch, billionaire Elon Musk has much to offer to the world. Be it his aim to colonise Mars or concerns regarding the fast-paced development of AI, Musk often makes headlines and is one of the most-known personalities of the tech world.

His biography, penned by Walter Isaacson, was launched recently and it takes us through his journey, from a shy and socially awkward child in South Africa to the billionaire that he is today. The book also briefly touches upon how Musk, as a teenager, was fond of reading and what made him into the engineer that he is today.

According to his biography, Musk would read whenever he got the chance. Be it the encyclopaedias in his father's office or superhero books, he was inspired by the books that he read. A book in his father's office described inventions that would be made in future and little Elon would read it over and over. This book had an idea of a rocket, propelled by an ion thruster, using particles rather than gas for thrust. Musk told Isaacson that this book was what first made him think about going to other planets.

More specifically, the books that appealed to Musk as a child were - The Moon is a Harsh Mistress, Isaac Asimov's Foundation series and The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy.

Robert Heinlein's The Moon is a Harsh Mistress was first published in 1966. In the book, a supercomputer called Mike gains consciousness and helps the protagonists during a rebellion. Mike even sacrifices itself for the cause of the rebellion. According to Isaacson, this book led Musk to think if AI will be for the good for humanity or be a threat to the living.

The next book that was Musk's favourite is Isaac Asimov's Foundation series. The books focus on laws of robotics and one of these is the Zeroth Law. This law states that a robot may not harm a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm. Other two laws that the book talks about are a robot obeying human beings' orders and protecting its own existence as long as it doesn't conflict with other laws.

These ideas motivated Musk to make space-travel possible and harness the power of AI for the good of humans.

In June 2018, Musk, in a tweet, said that the Zeroth Law from the book was 'fundamental' to the creation of SpaceX.

The third book that influenced Musk the most, as per Isaacson, is Douglas Adams' The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. Musk, while speaking to Isaacson, admitted that the book helped him 'come out of his existential depression' as a teenager.

The book tells the story of a human rescued by a spaceship before the earth gets destroyed. He then explores the galaxy and attempts to understand the meaning of life, the universe, and everything. The book also talked about a supercomputer that answered a question by humans that confused them even more. The question was about life, universe and everything. The computer then says that the problem is that they (humans) never really knew what the question was.

This lesson from the book stayed with Musk, as per his biography. The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy also elaborates on the idea that we all are living in a simulation that is being controlled by superior beings. Musk, after reading this book, has been fascinated with the thought.

Science-fiction, thus, took up majority of Musk's time as a child and influenced his ideas about what he wants to do and the companies he wants to build. 

 

Time may not be real !

  One of the most fundamental elements of the universe, time may not be real but an illusion created by quantum physics, suggests a new stud...